Thread:Edacnik/@comment-26084195-20151121000555/@comment-26084195-20151121090359

Patrick.vtap wrote: Since the King's Men didn't exist at the time, there were no Black Numenorean/Faithful division. Look, my point still stands. Why would Numenor give a sapling of Nimloth, the last surviving descendant of Telperion and a symbol of their friendship with the Elves, as well as one of the things that makes Numenor so special, to a port town in southern Middle Earth? The answer: They wouldn't. Also, it is stated that Isildur's sapling is the only surviving descendant of Nimloth.