Thread:High Prince Imrahil/@comment-25356210-20160118035651/@comment-26295802-20160118041549

Heartgold1234 wrote: High Prince Imrahil wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote: High Prince Imrahil wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote: It's more likely that Itallië would be resurrected than Imrahil, but she isn't going to be. Yes, but all your main characters aren't killed off yet. ..

Basically, the theory is that the Valar would see the work Imrahil did and allow him to return and continue the fight against the shadow. He wouldn't have had Valinorian powers or anything. It's not their decision, it's Eru's. They don't just snap their fingers and let things happen. And Eru wouldn't see the point, you're just a man. You imply that elves are more important to Eru then men, and I don't really think that's the case. . . They aren't more important, but you can't resurrect them. They need to be in Mandos (or spirits) to do that, and men don't go to Mandos. Correct me if I'm wrong, but aren't there conflicting legends about whether or not men go to Mandos?