Board Thread:Middle Earth Roleplays/@comment-26210095-20170505112915/@comment-27097330-20170521171617

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Morgul Lord wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Morgul Lord wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Morgul Lord wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Morgul Lord wrote: Patrick.vtap wrote: (Alright, this is getting somewhat confusing for me to follow. I'd like everybody to tell me everything they need resolved. Cair Andros:

Is it that unrealistic to have the catapult behind the defensive wall and still do damage? I can change it if it isn't.

How effective is the fire attack against the invading army? Unrealistic to do damage? No, I just think it's a little unrealistic to expect a single shot to do a whole lot. With a few shots, some might be indirect hits, or the odd lucky direct hit, but it's going to be massively handicapped. Aside from it essentially being the volatile Greek fire? But that's just fire. You're not going to get incredibly far with just fire. It's fire, but it isn't exactly a conventional fire that you put out with water and it's all over (some sources even claim water would just ignite it, though I doubt your soldiers would know that if it did or didn't actually do that). And in the same way as fire, it's not terribly effective at killing people when compared to something like, you know, a cannonball at high speed. Which reminds me, how much ammo do you actually have? Ask Pat. I gave it like a week each to get down the Harad coast and back. Nurn has had more than enough time to muster it's forces and march through Osgiliath.