Board Thread:Roleplay Ideas/@comment-26453572-20150825033610

I was thinking earlier, what would it be like if we did a reenactment of LOTR, but with more humor? I was thinking that we could separate the three main parts into the six divisions that Tolkien made when writing the books. There are two sort of titles for some of these, so I'll just think about which one is better if this idea works out.

The Fellowship of the Ring

Part One: The First Journey/The Ring Sets Out

Part Two: The Journey of Nine Companions/The Ring Heads South

The Two Towers

Part Three: The Treason of Isengard

Part Four: The Journey of the Ringbearers/The Ring Goes East

The Return of the King

Part Five: The War of the Ring

Part Six: The End of the Third Age/The Return of the King

With that, I have some questions for all of you.


 * What should they be based off of, the books or the movies?


 * Should extra characters be allowed, or should it be kept at the original characters of the chosen version?

If this all goes well, I will make a separate page for us to apply for certain characters. Though this is a comedy, and the characters won't always be serious, I don't expect/want Sauron to suddenly act like an average six year old girl. I expect a villain who can maintain a balance of seriousness and comedy. Anyway, what do you guys think about this? Would this make a good RP? 