Thread:High Prince Imrahil/@comment-26210095-20160903131100/@comment-26453572-20160903132122

That was the worst idea ever, I was glad when it ended. If Dol Amroth unified with Umbar, do you think Gondor would look at it and go "Oh, gee, they seceded only to form a kingdom with our lifelong enemies, oh well, I guess we're still best buddies, because that's hardly a problem!"?

No! Dol Amroth would be charged with high treason and mercilessly attacked by all of Gondor and its allies until their lands were reclaimed, and it will prevent several lore events from occurring in the process. And Umbar certainly wouldn't be strong enough to help their northern lands without ruining themselves trying to do so, not after the damaging war they just went through.