Board Thread:News and Announcements/@comment-26184570-20151011011430/@comment-25344655-20151011014444

Argali1 wrote: Galad always keeps a supply. There is such a thing as trading. Again, it isn't because it is non-cannon, it is because it is impossible. Tolkien never said that There weren't other species in the southern parts of Arda, but he did say that Eru is the creator of the universe. There was NOTHING before him. Glosur could have come into existance after Eru and the Ainur sang everything into existance, but it would be incredibly impossible to be before that. The only way for Glosur to be that old would be if he was an Ainur of some kind. Any other random spirit came directly after, as before Eru and the Ainur created the universe for things to exist in, there was only the timeless halls, and if you are from the timeless halls, that means that you are an Ainur. The only way for Glosur to that old would be for him to be a Maia. You realize I never said he wasn't, right?