Thread:Argali1/@comment-27097330-20160515171828/@comment-26347028-20160516211637

The Lord of Minas Morgul wrote: Why can't we just accept what Tolkien wrote as what happened? Why does everyone think that Tolkien wrote a bunch of lies for his world and never said what the truth was?

These are just wild theories that people come up with to make Tolkien's world fit to what they would have it be, not what he made it to be. He himself made it very complex. You will excuse me if I misinterpret the internal politics. However, it's better than disregarding them as you do.

"Wild theories" eh? How about you debunk it then, if it's so wild?