Thread:Argali1/@comment-26210095-20161218235442/@comment-26347028-20161222162033

Argali1 wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Argali1 wrote:

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Patrick.vtap wrote:

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Patrick.vtap wrote:

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Patrick.vtap wrote:

Edacnik wrote: Remember that they have more money, technology, and actor choices... But yes, Rogue One might be the best of them all, though I will still love the feel the old movies (4,5,6) contained. And Force Awakens wasn't that good by the way. The OT is by far the best. TFA was okay, it wasn't great. A worthy sequel, but it could have been much better. I hope they go in a different direction for SW 8. Honestly, the OT haven't stood the test of time. I thought TFA was better, although I must admit that Rogue One was better still.

I knew Tarkin was CGI. Don't know how, and throughout I kept telling myself he wasn't, but he still didn't feel right.

Anyway, what got at me the most was how the "heroic" music was playing when they rammed the star destroyer into the other, then into the shield. All I could think was "thousands upon thousands of people crew that ship. Most of them because they know no better". But no, we're supposed to support the Rebels upon their suicide quest, and the mindless slaughter that came with it.

Also, the mechanised units on the ground seemed to melt like butter from the fleet, but were impregnable on the ground. I found that hard to swallow. As I said, the TFA was good, it just wasn't great.

They still did a hell of a ood job with him, though.

Well, although I don't think that was a good thing to do, they did sign themselves to the rebel cause with a large chance of dying. The people in Jedha were innocents.

Have to agree there. Aye. The fact I thought it was my head playing tricks on me does say a lot about how good of a job they did.

I think they showed how Jedha was something they weren't supposed to do fairly well, and that to me it seemed to be simply a declaration of sheer power by the Empire and then another by the fact they were able to cover it up. Well, it was. But more people probably died in Jedha then on the Hammerhead. I'm not talking about on the Hammerhead. I'm talking about on the Star Destroyers. The people on the Star Destroyers know what they're doing. So? So they're not inoscent civilian casualties. Honestly, at the point in the story it's at, the Alliance really should have surrendered. They were unnecessary casualties, and the Rebels were the antagonists.