Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-26210095-20160404001701/@comment-26210095-20160404230703

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: TheShade6 wrote: All this time of being strict to the lore and now when it doesn't work in your favor you act as if its just a game of telephone between fictional characters? Have I said it is wrong? I'm stating that it could have been. The whole premise of the Red Book of Westmarch is that it's a book, rather obviously. Why, if it is supposed to be a story, should Frodo be making an effort to remember everything exactly as it was? The Silmarillion is a testament to such efforts; and there are questionable points even there. The fact that such a book by the Elves is questionable makes the Red Book of Wesmarch into possibly quite the fairy-tale; but, of course, based upon truth. You are pretty much destroying all that makes the Lord of the Rings the Lord of the Rings.