Thread:MrHobit1234/@comment-26210095-20151103154735/@comment-26210095-20151103155725

It is never stated that Gondor had a greater population. For all you know, Umbar had many colonies and such in the south (which it did, in my version of Umbar). Aragorn scraped all the men he could for this attack, and he could only get 6,000, with a few being left at Cair Andros.