Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25606723-20160721141729/@comment-25606723-20160723134055

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Tybereous wrote:

High King Ithilion wrote: I'm sorry, I know I never play on this wiki, but I've been reading through the latest comments and it seems to me that not demoting Heart is totally fair. If you don't break rules, you can't be demoted. For a long time on the LotR Mod wiki, MG was severely disliked. But was he demoted? No. And now he is generally liked by all. Why do you want to end Heart's time as a mod? What did she do? Again, I'm sorry to post, as this isn't my community, but I'm quite curious. Severe chat abuse (Banning/kicking those she doesn't agree with), causing and pursuing arguments beyond their logical end, telling users that they aren't welcome, etc etc. Severe chat abuse is either highly debatable, or entirely flawed in argument anyway.

And I do believe there are always two sides to an argument. If that's a crime, I do believe you deserve a demotion too, along with many others.

Telling users they aren't welcome? You have absolutely no understanding of what these people have done in the past. If you've actually ever suffered from harassment, you'd understand. Infact, just to prove a point, I'm getting Rhuardhrí on here now. Severe chat abuse is entirely legit. Lady Melron was demoted instantly for kicking Ed for hating on her brother in an extreme way, and what you could call 'starting a riot'. You have done much worse, and noone has had a second thought.

When the other side has no interest in continuing the argument, or when the argument becomes a pissing contest, it needs to end. I would like to point out that I asked you guys to stop the confederate flag argument towards the beginning because it was already at that point.

You told Imrahil that he wasn't welcome. If you havn't already deleted the comment, I can find it. You told Red several times that he wasn't welcome, despite him not breaking any rules. I seem to remember telling me that on chat at one point...I can go on.