Thread:High Prince Imrahil/@comment-26210095-20160903131100/@comment-26347028-20160904093101

The Lord of Minas Morgul wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Lord of Minas Morgul wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: The Lord of Minas Morgul wrote: Patrick.vtap wrote: The Lord of Minas Morgul wrote: That was the worst idea ever, I was glad when it ended. If Dol Amroth unified with Umbar, do you think Gondor would look at it and go "Oh, gee, they seceded only to form a kingdom with our lifelong enemies, oh well, I guess we're still best buddies, because that's hardly a problem!"?

No! Dol Amroth would be charged with high treason and mercilessly attacked by all of Gondor and its allies until their lands were reclaimed, and it will prevent several lore events from occurring in the process. And Umbar certainly wouldn't be strong enough to help their northern lands without ruining themselves trying to do so, not after the damaging war they just went through. Oh, okay then. Sorry if I pissed you off somehow... I was more concerned about the problems it would cause. If you thought that was, bad, you know that a certain member of this wiki will be 10x worse.. And Imrahil in particular won't enjoy that... If there was opposition to what you said, would you not argue the case? Of course I would, I just know you're more extreme in your actions and more protective of lore than I am. I gave them a dose of my anger about the idea to spare these two from the entirety of yours if they went through with it. And if they basically ignored me as they have you here, then the outcome would be entirely similar. If they oppose you as they presumably would me, the outcome would again be similar. The problem is not to do with me being extreme, Minas. And have they truly demoted me? Really mature of you there wasn't it. As for that, no, just as they didn't demote me for anything like this (nor was I technically demoted). What they "demoted" me for was the public opinion. To say the least, an unwarranted hate train. So your snarky remark isn't even correct. Had you been basically forced to either admit defeat, or continue, then as shown in the Confederacy thing, it's clear no one will admit defeat. So therefore I would implore you to stop being a hypocrite, and for that matter, so would really anyone - and therefore anyone else would be a hypocrite to attempt this highly flawed argument.

Let's face it, I got "demoted" because "people" hated me, for what amounted to nothing. So stop using flawed reasons to pretend it was otherwise. Hypocritical reasons, might I add.