Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25604636-20160125163804/@comment-26005135-20160126214513

Heartgold1234 wrote:

Edacnik wrote:

High Prince Imrahil wrote:

Edacnik wrote: Well there is nothing stopping it, so it's totally reasonable. There's nothing stopping a race of man-eating griffons that help Sauron and are led by another exiled Valar either, but we're not RPing that. . . My point is that a faction of elves down in Harad is no more uncanon than a Maia girl who procreated with the first prince of dol Amroth then took control of the TOTALLY WILLING Avari. Because they don't give a crap that an outlander is now their communist leader.

If you think my stuff isn't canon, then you can delete your stupid Hyprocritist comments and scrap your now back water arguments.

Since you can't seem to get the points I'm laying down; Elves in Harad are no more uncanon than this BS character you call "Itallië." 1. She isn't a Maia.

2. That was Imrahil's idea, and the times of her arrival do infact coincide with when Herendil was doing stuff in Lindon.

3. If you haven't noticed, that took time. And she isn't even the leader. She's the leader of 1/6 of them, roughly speaking.

4. Communist? I myself would class myself a capitalist, and she's literally me as an elf.

5. Please refrain from insulting people, even if it's only implied.

6. Elves in Harad are stupidly unreasonable, whereas there's a fair chance that a few Vanyar would be sent off to Endorë. Whether it be Itallië or whoever, there's a fair chance some went. There is no chance at all, or nigh on that, that elves would be in Harad. How did I not see this earlier with all the 'elves in harad' stuff.

It would be possible if the elves ''did not write their history for the world to see and asked their kin to pretend not to notice them for the sake of stealth. ''Like it or not, it would be possible.