Board Thread:Character Discussion Board/@comment-26184570-20151204055913/@comment-27718380-20151204221009

I will point out that all elves could do was telepathy, all the rest stemmed from immortality and being able to learn more things from that. There would be no way of having plasma therefore, and any form of gun is wildly out of place anyway. Certainly that one is beyond redemption. The second ones make no sense, as firstly the Noldor weren't seafarers, so they would be Falmari. Secondly, Falmari wouldn't travel so far from their kin, and third the Valar cannot change the form of the elves, that is a natural process. Finally, there is no mithril in Harad. The Valar cannot make you immortal, and there wouldn't be Oliphaunts there as they lived in the jungle.