Board Thread:Roleplay Ideas/@comment-26065062-20160713125226/@comment-26553378-20160722124955

i have something to point out,

yes we get it its almost literally starwars with middle earth characters inserted unless you actually read it.

names? honestly do you know how hard it is to get a completely original name nowadays? (although fine he somehow managed to rip-off almost every single one from tolkien)

also it has real magic,(not the cruddy i have like 5 people that show up in more than one page that even come close in all of the series, that one elf lady that i always forget the name of, gandalf, sauron, saurumon, and tom bombadil) and a more substantial aproach at dragons than 'oh no evil firedrake steal all our gold and eat all our women' instead he actually has them as magical beings.

and he was 16 his world was probably tolkien and star wars as im sure most of ours are right now as well (oh yeah school too), so you cant really blame him for ripping off races and plots from both.

overall he didnt do to bad i mean i really cant blame you if you decided it sucked after the first couple of pages because it is ripping off star wars and tolkien till almost half-way through other than the shade. but the main thing is, yes classic plot-line with almost nothing extra, but plot isnt everything (well kind of) he did an amazing job with the magic, and i personally loved the series (except for the socalled 'stalking' part Patric.vtap pointed out earlier)