Thread:Auraestus/@comment-25356210-20160321214339/@comment-26347028-20160323071842

High Prince Imrahil wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

High Prince Imrahil wrote:

162.194.126.178 wrote: A few badly needed fixes:

Crossover lore must die, it wrecks immersion, and ME factions have trouble counteracting stuff like lightsabers.

Utopias need be destroyed as unrealistic, they have no flaws, and make no sense.

And, races that don't exist in Tolkien's lore should be wiped from the wiki. Slightly deviant, and sparse variants of existing ones are okay. I disagree with the second... The canon elves are very much a utopian society. They attempt to be, but they aren't. In what way would you say they aren't utopian? I mean, besides a few isolated incidents of Kin-slaying in the First Age..... They are constantly under some form of attack, and are protected only by either their true isolationist nature or the power of a ring. Rivendell and Lindon have elves leaving all the time for the true Utopia, Valinor.