Board Thread:Random RP/@comment-25129884-20151115174509/@comment-26453572-20151117124414

What's unrealistic is the tactics involved. Gondor had some of the best armies in Middle Earth, but they were still driven out of Osgiliath by sheer numbers. In fact, the reason they faced defeat at the siege of Minas Tirith is because of the numbers they faced, and the numbers they would face before the army of the dead killed all the corairs. Then the grey company, Aragorn, Legolas, and Gimli joined the fight, giving them a few more men, and the battle was won. So even if clan Kor is good, I don't think they could hold out for weeks, or months. It would've taken either weeks or months to get the message to the jungle, and it would've either taken weeks or months to send armies to aid them. Wether it takes weeks or months to get to the jungle from Umbar, it would take the same amount of time to get back, so that would take months for a round trip like that. The likely nonexistent return journey wouldn't matter, since the battle will have ended.