Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25604636-20160125163804/@comment-26005135-20160127223829

Heartgold1234 wrote:

Berry6419 wrote: The Noldor / Sindar. I was thinking the Sand Elves themselves hid those books somewhere. And if a Sand Elf hides something, you can be sure never to find it again.

As for the Dol Amroth thing, all that's around is Haradrim, and we sure ain't letting them in! Well, yeah, you can keep your secret books secret. I thought you meant other races. And as for the latter point, if you don't allow immigration they'll eventually either become suspicious and invade, or you'll slowly wither away by them not wanting to deal with you. What if they don't know we're here? Which is the whole point of hiding the cities in the first place.