Thread:Patrick.vtap/@comment-26295802-20160305203536/@comment-26210095-20160305215522

Interesting... I actualy like.

This fits with Umbar's style of fighting, which is almost identical to Blitzkrieg. The Battle of Tarnost would have ruined the Umbarian advantage of suprise, and the Gondorians would have won.

I could see some kind of Suprise Attack on Tirith Aear by the Rangers of Castamir, that failed but assasinated an important official (one of Imrahil's sons?) and stole important documents. The attack was supposed to be upon the life of Imrahil/

Perhaps Veantur and Imrahil can have some kind of very personal rivalry. Both Veantur and Imrahil are brilliant military minds, Veantur was the tactician that took back the Crossings of Poros and resulted in one of Gondor's most embarrasing military defeats in Harondor. Perhaps Imrahil was there, and that is where their rivalry began?