Board Thread:Questions and Answers/@comment-27718380-20160130182100/@comment-26863727-20160404020503

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote:

Aramirtheranger wrote:

Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: That's right, ask me anything. I don't matter about the subject, and it can be personal or RP directed. However, please refrain from anything provocative or discriminatory. Wait, new question: why are you so strictly a lore purist? Everybody who isn't one explains why, but I have never seen a purist explain their reasons... one of those weird curiosities. It was designed to be the way it was. To go against such a thing would be, well, going against the original itself. To add, say, Elder Scrolls things into Endorë just does not fit, for instance. And it's that layer of realism, that purity that I look for. I don't honestly mind if your faction is reasonable and runs alongside the canon, but if it collides with it - as almost every single one here does - that is when I have a problem. It was written in a specific way, hence why it should stay so. So... you think things should be as they are but you also sometimes make very Feminist comments. I'm getting conflicting signals here.

So, since in lore the Silmarillion was written by Elves, if the Elves wouldn't have encountered something (such as if it was only around in the deepest reaches of Far Harad), then would you consider it A-OK if it wasn't unbalanced?