Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25604636-20160125163804/@comment-27718380-20160125202438

Edacnik wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote: Edacnik wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote: I infact say yes, as every one (even Glosur's to an extent) is very unrealistic and requires a huge level of 'ifs' and truly unlikely circumstances. There has to be some limit, or we will have to get rid of them. Say goodbye to Itallië then. :)

Also, say goodbye to United Haradrim, Speg. My point is that the Elven Order in your words were stuck in a cave for years on end. Or someone like that, and Sand Elves also make no sense. A Minya being sent off as a proto-istari does however fit in with what happens later. That's The Red elves... Not my faction.

Makes no sence? They would pretty much be dark elves, which are totally canon. They are no more unreasonable than a Maia elf... The point that makes no sense is the set of motions needed for them to be in action. The Avari, on the other hand, have been there since time immemorial, so you cannot dispute their beginnings. And for the last time, Itallië is only a Maia when the RP allows unreasonable things like Galad and you into it - which both go fairly directly against the canon in places.