Thread:Edacnik/@comment-26084195-20151121000555/@comment-26084195-20151121010228

Patrick.vtap wrote: This was in the days of peace. But Umbar was being used by the Black Numenorians. Plus, why would they give you a sapling to begin with? Umbar was, at the time, a port/fortress city, not a full-on nation. Besides, Nimloth the Fair was meant to be special, and kept closely guarded as one of the extra-special things about Numenor. I honestly can't think of any reason they'd give a sapling to Umbar.