Board Thread:Custom Lore Development/@comment-25356210-20160114013619/@comment-27718380-20160116001259

Edacnik wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote: James of the iron hills wrote: Heartgold1234 wrote:

James of the iron hills wrote:

Heartgold1234 wrote: Also, Lorien held off repeated attacks from Dol Guldur and in the end Galadriel cleansed Mirkwood. Now, Nenya would've been at play wherever the battle is so you have to also think about that. Also, Gundabad would lose against any form of pikemen and archer group. Pikes take out the wargs, archers the orcs. Gundabad probably has the biggest population in all MIddle Earth though, they are perhaps the greatest horde nation in all Middle Earth, they alone were a powerful match for MIrkwood, all of Durin's Folk, Esargoth and the Eagles. Escaroth had little effect, and really the eagles would come anyway to any battle if entirely necessary. Basically, Sindar and Durin's Folk. And weakly armed Sindar besides.

Still, overall about two full factions worth (Sindar+Eagles+Esargoth=full kingdom roughly) and two vert strong factions at that. I think they deserve their position. I should remind you that these were from the Grey Mountains aswell, and that the Dwarves only had 500 warriors in the battle. Get your facts straight. It's not like Tolkien make LOTR or The Hobbit a documentary, so stop. http://lotr.wikia.com/wiki/Battle_of_Five_Armies