Thread:Argali1/@comment-26210095-20160229213107/@comment-26347028-20160316163005

Edacnik wrote: Maltalidenta Kwuitidherali wrote: Both non-canonical sources. Not really...

The Silmarilion wasn't fully completed by Tolkien, and had many missing spots, but that doesn't make it non canon. But the very idea of it is that it's a collection of things considered canon, things neither unfinished, nor a whole thing entirely. So yes, they are very much non-canonical. And while the Silmarillion had many iffy areas, it was for the most part finished. Unlike these Unfinished Tales.